• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Login/ Register
  • Editorial Team
  • Get Involved

Exeposé Online

Making the headlines since 1987

Exeposé Online
  • Home
  • News
      • Local
      • COVID-19
      • University News
  • Comment
  • Features
      • National
      • Worldwide
      • Politics
      • Interviews
  • Science
      • News
      • Lite Science
      • Common Misconceptions
      • Environment
      • Health
      • Technology
  • Sport
  • Lifestyle
      • Fashion and Beauty
      • Features
      • Food
      • Wellbeing
      • Sustainability
  • Music
      • Interviews
      • Features
      • Live Reviews
      • Album Reviews
      • Single Reviews
  • Screen
      • Reviews
      • Features
      • Interviews
      • Festivals and Awards
  • Arts + Lit
      • Interviews
      • Features
      • Reviews
      • Creative Writing
  • Amplify
  • International
  • Multilingual
  • News
  • Comment
  • Features
  • Science
  • Tech
  • Sport
  • Lifestyle
  • Music
  • Screen
  • Arts + Lit
  • Amplify
  • International
  • Multilingual
Home / Amplify

Justice Ayesha Malik: Outlawing the Two-Finger Test and Her Indelible Mark on Pakistan’s Justice System

Justice Ayesha Malik: Outlawing the Two-Finger Test and Her Indelible Mark on Pakistan’s Justice System

Supreme Court of Pakistan

Feb 14, 2022 – by Lina Idrees

Lina Idrees writes about the recent appointment of Justice Ayesha Malik as Pakistan’s first female Supreme Court judge and reflects on her seminal judgement banning the ‘two-finger test’ in Pakistan.

TW: sexual violence, rape

It’s been a year since the Supreme Court of Pakistan abolished the ‘two-finger’ test – a decision which was long overdue for victims of sexual violence. This landmark ruling was passed by no one other than Justice Ayesha Malik, a judge of the Lahore High Court who has recently been approved by Pakistan’s top judicial commission as a judge of the Supreme Court of Pakistan – a defining moment for Pakistan’s judicial system. Justice Ayesha Malik made international headlines last year after banning the ‘two-finger’ test for rape survivors and has continued to make history after being sworn in as the first female Supreme Court judge. 

The colonial-era test which Justice Ayesha Malik ruled as unconstitutional involves inserting two fingers into the vagina of the victim to test its laxity and for the presence of a hymen to determine whether or not the victim is “habituated to sexual intercourse”. In cases of rape, consent isn’t something that can be ‘objectively quantified’, and Zainab Z. Malik argues that the test is used to ‘decode’ consent. If the victim isn’t a virgin, courts are reluctant to consider a victims claim of rape because the victim character isn’t in line with what is deemed ‘chaste’ or ‘pure’. 

In the rare instance in which a victim of sexual assault chooses to seek legal recourse in Pakistan, they often find a shadow cast upon their credibility after the application of the test which upholds harmful socio-cultural stereotypes about women and is prejudiced towards rape victims.

In the rare instance in which a victim of sexual assault chooses to seek legal recourse in Pakistan, they often find a shadow cast upon their credibility after the application of the test which upholds harmful socio-cultural stereotypes about women and is prejudiced towards rape victims. One example of this is the case of Mukhtaran Mai, a victim of gang-rape and an individual who was denied access to justice as a result of the application of the test in arguably its most discriminatory manner. 

In 2002, Mukhtaran Mai was gang-raped by four men as a result of a tribal dispute in the rural village of Meerwala. Mukhtaran Mai went through four stages of legal proceedings, spanning nine years and ending with the Supreme Court of Pakistan’s disappointing decision in 2011. Throughout the judgement, Mukhtaran Mai was described as a ‘divorcee’ – a crucial fact pertaining to her case. Why? Because the two-finger test ‘proved’ she wasn’t a virgin and drew a distinction in the delay of filing the First Information Report (FIR): 

“… in a case of an unmarried virgin victim of a young age, whose future may get stigmatized, if such a disclosure is made, if some time is taken by the family to ponder over the matter that situation cannot be held at par with a grownup lady, who is a divorcee for the last many years…”

Justices Saquib Nisar and Shakirullah Jan, Para. 23

Had Mukhtaran Mai been an unmarried virgin, would the 8 day delay in the FIR at the police station (through no fault of her own) played a role in determining her credibility? Probably not. The courts perception of Mukhtaran Mai was influenced by the two-finger test which wasn’t admissible evidence to prove the rape took place but evidence that proved she wasn’t a virgin. It makes you wonder how many rape survivors who have struggled to prove their case in court may have benefited from the abolishment of the test earlier. According to Aitzaz Ahsan, the lead lawyer on Mukhtaran Mai’s case, ‘it could have been a huge factor tilting the decision in favour of Ms. Mai as woman’s virginity would not have been up for questioning’. 

In an article he wrote for The News International, Aitzaz Ahsan praised Justice Ayesha Malik’s comments about the weight given to a woman’s virginity in ascertaining the crime of rape. In the seminal judgement of Sadaf Aziz v The Federation she stated: 

“The conclusion drawn from these (virginity or two-finger) tests about a woman’s sexual history and character is a direct attack on her dignity and leads to adverse effects on the social and cultural standing of a victim. It is also discriminatory as the test is carried out primarily to ascertain whether or not she is sexually active, for which there appears to be no justification as being sexually active is irrelevant to the incident of rape or sexual abuse” 

Justice Ayesha Malik, Para. 28

The distinction between a virgin and non-virgin, a married woman and a divorcee, and the distinction “…that men are independent and women are men’s dependents” aren’t simply unfortunate socio-cultural stereotypes that women have to deal with on a daily basis but are reinforced in Pakistan’s judicial system which uphold such stereotypes through legal norms and undermine women’s fundamental rights. While the year old judgement is incredibly important and a step towards a fairer and more just approach to cases of sexual violence, it was simply a step. In a country where rape cases are underreported and victims of sexual violence face such a stigma, the removal of such a hurdle rooted in misogyny with no scientific basis is the bare minimum development for our justice system. 

The recent appointment of Justice Ayesha Malik to the Supreme Court has made this year-old step feel like one of many to come because it is decisions of this seminal nature by women like herself which slowly contribute towards what I think will amount to a revolutionary change across Pakistan’s legal and socio-cultural landscape. Pakistan needs more women in positions of power to trigger this change and I look forward to more of Justice Ayesha Malik’s momentous contributions to our legal system.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Feb 14, 2022 By Lina Idrees Filed Under: Amplify, World News, Amplify News Tagged With: pakistan, Supreme Court, Justice Ayesha Malik, Mukhtaran Mai, Aitzaz Ahsan

Primary Sidebar

exepose

The official Instagram account for Exeposé, the University of Exeter's independent student newspaper.
Old issues here: issuu.com/exeposeexeter

✨XMedia Christmas Ball✨ A huge thank you to e ✨XMedia Christmas Ball✨

A huge thank you to everyone who came to the ball, to Big Band for putting on an amazing performance, the Rougemont Hotel for hosting us and Ella Gant for capturing the night with these lovely photos!
🎉 Print Issue 726 is out on campus! 🎉 Our f 🎉 Print Issue 726 is out on campus! 🎉

Our front page covers the University's failure to uphold Individual Learning Plans (ILPs) as evidence for longer-term mitigation and student charity work being halted by the Guild's delay in updating their DBS policy. 

Inside we have an exclusive interview with Bella Enoizi, VP Education, Features analyses the outcome of the Kyle Rittenhouse case, Comment argues for and against the abolition of private schools, and Tech looks at cryptocurrency scams. Science also reveals how sleeping earlier may lower your risk of heart disease while Sport reviews Fight Night.

Over on our Exhibit pages, Lifestyle explores Christmas holiday traditions around the globe and evaluates the Exeter Christmas Market, Arts and Lit writers recommend their favourite non-fiction books, Music investigates Adele's comeback in the music industry and Screen discusses Taylor Swift's All Too Well: The Short Film.

#Exepose #UniversityofExeter #StudentMedia #StudentNewspaper #ILPs #disability #mitigation #DBS #ESV #STAR #mentalhealth #privateschools #ExeterChristmasMarket #AllTooWell #TaylorSwift #Adele30 #FightNight #Christmasfilms #PrintIssue
⌚Timings for the XMedia Ball ⌚ Although the ⌚Timings for the XMedia Ball ⌚ 

Although the publicised start is 7pm, we will be at the Rougemont Hotel from 6pm so feel free to arrive at that time. 

We would also appreciate if everyone could do a Lateral Flow Test before coming considering the new COVID variant.

🎄 6pm-7pm: Arrive, enjoy the hotel’s happy hour and your free cocktail, and have some photos taken! The photographer will arrive at 6:30pm, but you're welcome to take your own pics before then.

🎄 7:30pm: Dinner is served

🎄 9:30pm: A performance from Big Band

🎄 10:30pm-12am: Music and dancing!
📢 Print Issue 725 is out on campus and online! 📢 Print Issue 725 is out on campus and online!

Our front page reports on student Meningitis cases in Exeter and the Exeter University Rugby and Football Club's self-described 'Hymn Sheet' which contains parody-style songs some students have labelled sexist and classist.

Inside we have an interview with AU President Katy Dalglish, for and against Comment articles on landlords, and our first ever Satire pieces (anyone else think Cardiac Hill should be used as a ski venue?)! Science also discusses the link between Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) and mental health and Sport covers the Movember varsity basketball match between Exeter and Plymouth University, which raised £2048.

Over on our Exhibit pages, Lifestyle explores the toxic side of hustle culture, Music speaks to Pale Wave's frontwoman, Heather Baron-Gracie and Screen writers share their favourite Wes Anderson films.

https://issuu.com/exeposeexeter

#Exepose #UniversityofExeter #StudentMedia #StudentNewspaper #HymnSheet #EURFC #classism #sexism #landlords #Satire #CardiacHill #HustleCulture #WesAnderson #PaleWaves #PrintIssue
Tickets for the XMedia Christmas Masquerade Ball a Tickets for the XMedia Christmas Masquerade Ball at the Rougemont Hotel on Sunday 5th December (7pm) are now available! Please visit the Exeter Guild website (linked in story/info highlight) to buy.

Members Price: £28
Non-members Price: £33

Please note, we only have 45 tickets for Exeposé members so get them as soon as you can!

Any questions, feel free to DM us or comment below.

https://www.exeterguild.org/events/8281/41465/
🎄 Masque up, dress up and turn up to XMedia's C 🎄 Masque up, dress up and turn up to XMedia's Christmas Masquerade Ball! 🎄

We've joined forces with XpressionFM, Razz Magazine and XTV to bring you the event of the year.

When:
Sunday 5th December, 7pm 🎊

Where:
Rougemont Hotel, Devonshire Suite 🏨

Price (includes a 3 course meal and cocktail):
£28 for members, £33 for non-members 🎅

Bring your friends and family!

Details on how to buy a ticket to the event will be shared soon.

We hope to see you there!

#Exepose #XMedia #ChristmasBall #Masquerade #RougemontHotel #Exeter
🥳 Print Issue 724 is out on campus! 🥳 Our f 🥳 Print Issue 724 is out on campus! 🥳

Our front page news stories cover both horrifying and pleasant student experiences with estate agents, Cardens, and Jacob Rees-Mogg's controversial comments at an event organised by the Exeter University Conservative Association. 

Inside we have COP26 coverage and an exclusive interview with the USS Pensions Officer for the UCU, a Feature article detailing local support for sexual assault survivors and a Science piece on how TikTok is revolutionising science communication.

Over on our Exhibit pages, Lifestyle discusses breast cancer signs and how to self-examine, Arts and Lit explore the concept of streaming theatre online and Screen spotlight some of the best (and worst) musicians-turned-actors.

#Exepose #UniversityofExeter #StudentMedia #StudentNewspaper #Cardens #JacobReesMoggs #COP26 #UCU #TikTok #TLC #TheatreOnline #PrintIssue
In case you didn't already know, Print Issue 723 i In case you didn't already know, Print Issue 723 is out on campus 🥳

Our front page covers the outrage and confusion over the Athletic Union's (now u-turned) decision to ban sport socials indefinitely and the boycotting of nightclubs in response to a rise in spiking. 

We also have an exclusive interview with Marion Ojua, VP Liberation and Diversity, who spoke about her day-to-day duties, Black History Month and diversity at the University of Exeter.

In our Comment section, one writer argues in favour of banning red meat on campus while Science spotlights the work of Black scientists and Sport looks at the career of former footballer, Viv Anderson. 

Over on our Exhibit pages, Lifestyle writers discuss important Black-owned fashion and beauty brands, Arts and Lit contributors share who their favourite Black artists are and Screen reviews Netflix's most popular show, Squid Game.

#Exepose #UniversityofExeter #StudentMedia #StudentNewspaper #AthleticsUnion #boycotts #spiking #BlackHistoryMonth #redmeat #SquidGame #VivAnderson #PrintIssue
We have an excellent number of candidates running We have an excellent number of candidates running for committee positions and now it's time to vote!

Members, please read each manifesto on the Exeter Guild website before submitting your ranks. 

Polls close Thursday 28th October at 23.59 ⏲️

Good luck to all candidates!

#Exepose #Elections
Follow on Instagram
This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Error: API requests are being delayed for this account. New posts will not be retrieved.

There may be an issue with the Instagram access token that you are using. Your server might also be unable to connect to Instagram at this time.

Tweets by Exeposé Lifestyle

Contact Us: editors@exepose.com

Since 1987, Exeposé has given a voice to Exeter students. Over the years, the determination and political fervour exhibited by students through Exeposé have helped shape the University we study at today. We have received national recognition for our award-winning campaigns, investigations and surveys, and always strive to provide students with high-quality news, comment and features.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in articles and comments do not reflect the views of Exeposé Online or the University of Exeter Student's Guild.

        


© 2022
Website design: Harry Caton and Ellie Cook
Webdesign & development: Harry Caton