Exeter, Devon UK • [date-today] • VOL XII
Home Comment What a Chinese taxi ride taught me about security

What a Chinese taxi ride taught me about security

Eva Holland explores how a taxi ride in China changed her perspective on security.
4 mins read
Written by
Inside a taxi in Chongqing, the city which inspired the film Blade Runner, also known as the Chinese Cyberpunk City (Via Eva Holland)

As I stepped into my Didi (China’s Uber) in Chongqing, a notification appeared on my phone, asking for permission to audio-record the ride. Now, being a former Dubai expat, non-democracies do not scare me, but the question still caught me off guard. Immediately, images of my phone being hacked popped into my head. I turned around to my partner and asked, ‘‘is this legal?’’.

This reform to Didi’s Hitch app comes following the murder of Li Mingzhu by one of Didi’s Hitch drivers who was suspected of stealing his father’s Hitch account, in May 2018. Wary of sexual violence, what I initially regarded as intrusion, turned to safety. Uber adopted the recording feature too, but as an extra option with prior passenger consent. However, with Didi? No recording, no riding. That is when it dawned on me: in China, safety is less a private matter and more a construct embedded in society.

Taxi services are only a microcosm of the East and West’s different understandings of security. From the perspective of a female foreigner visiting tourist-geared places with an unofficial guide, walking around at night, unable to speak Chinese, I felt safe. Conveniently, my partner is from Hong Kong, fluent in the local languages.

Despite my conglomerate of nationalities, I write this article from an Anglicised standpoint. Personally, I imagine the UK to be a middle ground for security, between places like Rio and Dubai.

In comparison to what I experienced in China, from a safety lens in British Ubers and taxis, security seems to be more of an individual responsibility, where you must take initiative by actively choosing to record and update your travel status. Protecting yourself is seen more as a social choice than a structural one. Whereas in China, the source of perceived danger appears to shift. I found that many international observers frame the primary risk not as street crime, but as state power, particularly in relation to Xinjiang, where policies toward the Uyghur population remain heavily contested. 

In comparison to what I experienced in China, from a safety lens in UK Ubers and taxis, security seems to be more of an individual responsibility, where you must take initiative by actively choosing to record and update your travel status. Protecting yourself is seen more as a social choice than a structural one.

Upon questioning my partner about this, I received this reply: ‘‘Honestly, it’s just propaganda. I’ll take you to a factory for you to see for yourself the type of conditions the workers live in.’’ 

My reality was a far cry from what I anticipated. We were taken into a showroom by the owners to see the sunglasses that they manufacture and we were also offered refreshments: ‘‘tea or coffee?’’ – I came prepared. ‘‘Light tea, no milk, no sugar ’’. The lady was so taken that she exclaimed something excitedly to my partner, and the group laughed. He turned to me: ‘‘She says she finds it funny how you asked for tea our way.’’ I was already in a Chinese time of my life before the trend took off.

Circling back to the original question of security, it depends on how one chooses to define it. From my observation, social cohesion is emphasised in China, which, having been raised in the British education system, makes the comparison feel more striking. 

In turn, it appears the paternalistic role the state plays prompts security, which is reflected in the nation’s collective attitude. In fact, the very word for Mandarin, ‘Putonghua’, literally translates to ‘common tongue’. Commonality manifests beyond politics; it is woven into language, culture and philosophy. In this context, privacy is traded for security, arguably in the name of the “greater good”. 

In turn, it appears the paternalistic role the state plays prompts security, which reflects in the nation’s collective attitude

How do we define feeling secure? Is safety a matter of privacy or security? As clients visiting a sunglasses factory, we were taken to the showroom, not the back rooms. If any shady business was occurring behind closed doors, we likely wouldn’t have seen it. Few foreigners gain this level of access in tightly controlled systems, after all.

I accept that I have experienced China at face value. Yet, China definitely surprised me. I arrived expecting sweatshops and surveillance. Instead, I visited factories and a real-life Blade Runner city. The people were friendly, the tea houses were as plentiful as pubs, and I tried slightly unusual food in all forms. But when people ask me, “what stood out to you the most in China?” I told them it was a taxi ride.

You may also like

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign Up for Our Newsletter